Current to September 26, 2026
It depends on how the deal is structured and what the lease says.
- In an asset sale, the lease usually has to be assigned to the buyer, which often needs the landlord’s consent.
- In a share sale, the tenant stays the same, but a change-of-control clause may still require landlord consent.
- Review the lease early and identify every consent and document needed.
- If the location is key, make the deal depend on securing it.
- The buyer will need to go through the landlord’s approval process and should start early. But the buyer should not sign the consent until the deal documents are mostly complete.
- Whether the lease moves with the business depends on the deal structure and the lease terms.
- An asset sale usually needs an assignment. A share sale may trigger a change-of-control clause, which means the landlord still needs to approve the transfer.
- Before contacting the landlord, check the lease for consent rules, response deadlines, and any right to take back the space or end the lease.
- Expect the landlord to negotiate. It may set its own conditions before it consents.
- An assignment alone usually does not release the seller or its guarantors. Get a written release.
- The purchase agreement should say who carries the risk of delay, cost, and refusal.
- Get the full lease file and check for defaults, arrears, repairs, fixtures, and renewal deadlines.
A buyer typically wants to continue operating the business from the same location without interruption. To do that, the buyer needs to confirm that the business is allowed to operate there, how much time is left on the lease, and what the space will cost. The buyer also needs a clear plan for how deposits, keys, fixtures, and lease obligations will pass on closing. The lease plan should fit with the purchase agreement, the financing, and the closing timeline, and the sale should stay confidential while it comes together.
Forgione Deal and Corporate Counsel is a Burlington business law firm acting for owners and buyers in business sales and acquisitions across the GTA, most often valued between $1 million and $15 million. Wes Forgione has closed more than 400 transactions. See: Selling Your Business | Buying a Business.
How the Deal Structure Affects the Lease
The first question is who the tenant will be after closing. The answer depends on how the deal is structured.
Asset Sale
In an asset sale, the buyer takes over the business, but the seller’s company is still the tenant. The lease has to be assigned to the buyer, and most commercial leases require the landlord’s consent to do that.
Shareholder approval is a separate step. If an Ontario company sells all or nearly all of its property outside its normal business, its shareholders must approve the sale by special resolution. That rule is in subsections 184(3) to (8) of the Business Corporations Act, and shareholders who vote against it may have dissent rights under section 185. That approval is in addition to the landlord’s consent. In a private, closely held company, it is rarely an issue.
Share Sale
In a share sale, the tenant company remains the same, but there are still steps that must be completed with the landlord to continue the lease effectively. Many leases treat a change of control or a share transfer as an assignment, which means landlord consent is required.
Buyers should review the lease before accepting an offer, and in particular read the definitions, exceptions, notice rules, and landlord remedies before settling on a deal structure.
Reorganization Before a Sale
Sellers often reorganize before a sale. They may move the business assets into a new company or amalgamate two existing companies. Many leases treat these steps as an assignment too, requiring landlord consent. Before completing a reorganization, check the lease to ensure you remain compliant, or it could cause problems with the landlord.
| Factor | Asset Sale | Share Sale | New Lease or Move |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consent trigger | Usually an assignment that needs consent | No assignment, but a change-of-control clause may require consent | Ending or subletting the old lease may need consent; the new site needs a new lease |
| Documents | Assignment and assumption, consent, and often an amendment | Share purchase documents plus any consent or waiver | New lease, plus any surrender or sublease |
| Seller exposure | Seller and guarantors may stay liable unless released | Tenant is unchanged and keeps its lease duties | Old lease liability continues unless ended with a release |
| Main risk | Consent is delayed, refused, or comes with costly conditions | Parties wrongly assume a share sale avoids the lease limits | The new site is not ready when the business must move |
Before the LOI: What to Check in the Lease
Review the lease before the letter of intent is signed. The price and the closing conditions both depend on it.
For the Seller
Gather the complete lease file: the lease, every amendment and side letter, past consents, and landlord notices. Confirm the rent is current and there are no defaults. Check whether you or anyone else signed a personal guarantee or indemnity. Sellers should attempt to be removed as a guarantor, although this isn’t always agreeable to the landlord.
For the Buyer
Ask for the lease early. A buyer often prices the business on the assumption that it can stay at the same address. A short remaining term, a weak renewal option, a use restriction, an unresolved default, or a landlord termination right can all undercut that assumption. Confirm:
- The legal names of the tenant and landlord.
- The premises, plus any parking, storage, or common area rights.
- The term, expiry date, and renewal notice deadlines.
- The permitted use, plus any exclusive or radius restrictions.
- The assignment, subletting, and change-of-control terms.
- Any landlord right to take back the space or end the lease.
- Any relocation or demolition clause.
- Base rent, percentage rent, and additional rent.
- Alteration, signage, and restoration duties.
- Deposits, prepaid rent, letters of credit, and guarantees.
Then ask three questions. Can each right be transferred? Does each option survive an assignment or control change? And must any existing breach be cured before the landlord consents?
Approaching the Landlord
When to Tell the Landlord
Most parties approach the landlord after the letter of intent is signed. Going earlier risks word of the sale reaching staff, customers, or competitors. Going later leaves too little time for the landlord to review and negotiate. Prior to approaching the landlord, review the lease carefully so you can negotiate intelligently. For example, the lease will specify how long the landlord has to respond, so build that time into the closing date. Use a confidentiality agreement, and share what the landlord needs to decide.
What to Send
A consent request usually includes the buyer’s legal name and ownership, financial statements, the planned use, references, and details of any guarantor. Send what the lease requires, in the form it requires. An incomplete request can delay the landlord’s answer or give it grounds to ask for more.
The Reasonableness Rule
Section 23 of Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act sets a default rule. Unless the lease clearly says otherwise, a landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment or sublease. A court can decide whether a refusal was reasonable and can allow the assignment. But the lease can contract out of that default. And a landlord’s right to take back the space is different from a consent right.
Ontario cases show how context drives the result:
- In Rabin v. 2490918 Ontario Inc. (2023 ONCA 49), the Ontario Court of Appeal held that a commercial landlord unreasonably withheld consent to a lease assignment by missing a contractually mandated response deadline and leveraging the consent process to demand a collateral benefit.
- Tradedge Inc. (Shoeless Joe’s) v. Tri-Novo Group Inc. (2009 ONCA 855) is a prominent Canadian commercial leasing case where the lease did not allow the landlord to withhold consent unreasonably. The Court confirmed that in such a case, a landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent to a lease assignment to achieve a collateral purpose, such as extracting higher rent.
- In 8167800 Canada Inc. (Lead Home Renovation) v. Denison Limited, 2024 ONCA 146, the Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld a decision addressing a commercial lease dispute where the tenant breached its “permitted use” clause by manufacturing kitchen cabinets on-site. The landlord sought to terminate the lease, but the motion judge granted the tenant the equitable remedy of relief from forfeiture, allowing it to maintain its tenancy on the condition that it immediately cease the unauthorized manufacturing and stick to the permitted use in the lease.
How Landlords Decide Whether to Approve a Buyer
When a landlord reviews a consent request, it is deciding whether the buyer is a tenant it would have chosen. Most landlords look at the same points:
- the financial strength of the company taking the lease, not just its owners
- whether that company is in good standing and who has authority to sign for it
- liens, judgments, or past lease defaults involving the buyer or its principals
- landlord and trade references
- whether the owners will give a personal guarantee
- whether the buyer’s planned use fits the space and the lease
- the deposit or other security the landlord wants
- proof of insurance before the buyer takes over
A buyer operating through a new company with no track record should expect closer review and a request for a guarantee. The seller has a stake in this too. A buyer the landlord can approve quickly keeps the closing timeline on track.
Our Tenant Quality Audit is the checklist we built for landlords screening a new tenant. A buyer can work through it to see the consent request from the landlord’s side before sending it.
What Landlords Commonly Ask For
Depending on the lease and its bargaining power, the landlord may want:
- Existing defaults cured, and its legal and admin fees paid.
- A new deposit or letter of credit, or stronger guarantees.
- Updated insurance or environmental terms.
- A lease amendment, different rent, or a new lease.
Whether a demand is allowed or reasonable depends on the lease and the facts. Do not agree to it in advance without deciding who pays and what happens if it is refused.
The Tenant Quality Audit is a 15-question checklist based on how landlords screen a new tenant. Work through it before the consent request goes in.
Open the Tenant Quality AuditWhat Each Side Needs to Protect
The Seller: An Assignment Is Not a Release
An assignment transfers the lease to the buyer, but it usually does not end the seller’s liability. The seller signed the lease, so the landlord can generally still look to the seller, and to anyone who guaranteed the lease, if the buyer stops paying rent or otherwise defaults. Most commercial leases also say expressly that the original tenant stays liable after an assignment. That exposure can last for the rest of the term and, depending on the wording, into any renewal or extension.
The only reliable way to end that exposure is a written release from the landlord. The seller should ask for one that releases the tenant company and every guarantor, effective on closing. Landlords often refuse, or agree only if the buyer is financially strong or gives its own guarantee.
If the landlord will not give a release, the seller should protect itself in the purchase agreement. It should include:
- an indemnity from the buyer for lease claims arising after closing
- security to back the indemnity, such as a guarantee from the buyer’s owners or a letter of credit
- a promise from the buyer to comply with the lease, and not to amend, extend, or assign it without the seller’s consent, since those changes could increase the seller’s liability
- a right for the seller to receive notice of any default and to see the lease records
- repayment of the seller’s legal costs if it has to enforce these rights
Keep in mind what an indemnity does and does not do. It decides who ultimately pays as between buyer and seller. It does not stop the landlord from suing the seller, and it is only worth as much as the buyer’s ability to pay.
The Buyer: Moving In and Operating on Closing Day
The buyer needs to know it can move in and operate the day the deal closes. That means a consent condition in the purchase agreement, enough time left on the lease to justify the price, and confirmation that zoning, licences, and the lease all allow its use. Match the lease file against payment records and a site visit, and check for environmental issues and who owns the fixtures.
A signed statement from the landlord, called an estoppel certificate, can confirm the lease terms and that there are no defaults. Read its wording and limits closely. If a lender is financing the purchase, it may want the landlord to sign a waiver about the lender’s rights to equipment on the premises. Raise this early. It is one more document the landlord has to agree to.
- A written release of the tenant and every guarantor
- A buyer indemnity if no release is given
- The deposit returned or credited on closing
- Rent and cost adjustments to the closing date
- Confidentiality until the landlord needs to know
- The landlord’s signed consent before closing
- The full lease file, including side letters
- An estoppel certificate
- Confirmation of zoning, licences, and permitted use
- Any landlord waiver its lender requires
What the Purchase Agreement Should Say
The purchase agreement should deal with the lease directly. First, it should set out how consent will be obtained:
- Who asks for consent. Say which party sends the request, by what date, and what information goes to the landlord.
- Who pays. Allocate the landlord’s fees and charges, and the cost of any work the landlord requires as a condition of consent.
- How hard each side must try. Set the level of effort each party must make to get consent, such as commercially reasonable efforts.
- Who decides on the landlord’s conditions. Say whether the buyer must accept conditions the landlord attaches to its consent, or can refuse them.
Second, it should protect both sides if the premises are essential to the deal:
- Consent as a closing condition. Make landlord consent a condition of closing, with an outside date that leaves room for the landlord’s response period under the lease.
- Cooperation. Require both sides to cooperate with the landlord and with each other until consent is obtained.
- Statements about the lease. Have the seller confirm the lease terms and that there are no defaults.
- Rent adjustments. Adjust rent, deposits, and other lease charges as of the closing date.
- Indemnities. The seller should cover lease obligations that arose before closing, and the buyer should cover those that arise after.
- What happens if consent is refused, delayed, or conditional. This is the most important term. Say whether the parties can extend the closing date, waive the condition, renegotiate, or end the deal.
- No unconditional duty to close. The buyer should not be required to close if it cannot lawfully move in and operate.
If the Landlord Says No or Stalls
A refusal or a long silence does not always end the deal. Do not treat silence as consent. The options include:
- Negotiate. Find out what the landlord needs. A larger deposit, a guarantee, or a lease amendment may resolve it.
- Apply to court. If the lease does not contract out of section 23, the tenant can ask a court to decide whether the refusal was reasonable. This takes time and money.
- Sublease. If the lease allows it, the seller keeps the lease and sublets to the buyer. The seller stays fully liable to the landlord.
- Sign a new lease. The landlord may prefer a new lease directly with the buyer, often on current market terms.
- Restructure. A share sale may avoid an assignment, but only if the lease has no change-of-control clause that applies.
- Adjust the price or walk away, as the purchase agreement allows.
A short interim occupancy deal can bridge timing, but only if it is lawful, insured, consistent with the lease, and carefully written. It should cover possession, payment, risk, access, licences, fixtures, indemnities, and a firm end date. It must not become an undisclosed assignment or an informal handshake.
Treat the landlord as a third party to the deal, with its own interests and its own timeline.
Closing Day
The closing checklist should include:
- The signed consent, and the assignment or new lease.
- Any amendment and release.
- Certificates, keys, access codes, and proof of insurance.
- Deposits, letters of credit, meter readings, and rent adjustments.
- Fixture and restoration terms, and any required notices.
- Confirmation that no new default arose before closing.
Who Does What, When
| Stage | Seller | Buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Before the LOI | Gather the lease file, confirm there are no defaults, and check for personal guarantees | Ask for the lease and check the term, renewal, use, consent, and change-of-control terms |
| LOI | Disclose known lease issues | Make the deal conditional on landlord consent if the location is key |
| Due diligence | Provide amendments, side letters, and landlord letters | Review the lease file, zoning, licences, and site, and prepare the consent package |
| Purchase agreement | Negotiate the release, indemnity, and who pays landlord costs | Negotiate the consent condition, outside date, and remedies |
| Landlord consent | Send or support the request and ask for a release | Provide financials, references, and any guarantee |
| Closing | Deliver keys, codes, and deposit adjustments | Receive the signed consent, estoppel certificate, and proof of insurance |
Suppose a buyer agrees to buy all the shares of a specialty retailer. It assumes no lease consent is needed, since the tenant will not change. Lease review shows the lease treats a transfer of voting control as an assignment. It also gives the landlord a right to take back the space.
We would raise the clause before the letter of intent is final, so the price and conditions reflect it. We would make landlord consent a condition of closing, with an outside date that allows for the lease’s response period. We would prepare the buyer’s consent package early, built around the checks landlords commonly run. And we would ask the landlord to confirm in writing that it will not use its right to take back the space. This is a general illustration, not a client matter.
Common Mistakes
- Both“Waiting until closing week to read the consent clause.”
- Buyer“Assuming a share sale never needs landlord consent.”
- Buyer“Missing a renewal notice deadline while the deal is being negotiated.”
- Both“Treating consent as automatic and ignoring the landlord’s right to take back the space.”
- Seller“Closing an assignment without a written release of the seller and its guarantors.”
- Both“Failing to allocate delay, landlord costs, and refusal risk in the purchase agreement.”
Frequently Asked Questions
No. It depends on the deal structure and the exact lease. Asset sales usually need consent to an assignment. Share sales and reorganizations may trigger a change-of-control or deemed assignment clause.
Most landlords review the financial strength of the company taking the lease, whether it is in good standing, any liens, judgments, or past lease defaults, and its references. They also check whether the owners will give a personal guarantee and whether the buyer’s use fits the lease. Our Tenant Quality Audit lists the checks landlords commonly run.
Section 23 of the Commercial Tenancies Act sets a default rule that consent cannot be unreasonably withheld, unless the lease clearly says otherwise. The lease wording, the proposed tenant, the use, the timing, and the landlord’s reasons all matter.
Not always. The tenant stays the same. But many leases treat a change in who controls the tenant as an assignment.
Usually not on its own. Get a written release from the landlord for the original tenant and every guarantor. A buyer indemnity alone does not stop the landlord from enforcing the lease against the seller.
Follow the lease’s notice and information steps, and record the timing and reasons. Assess your legal and contractual remedies, and use the purchase agreement’s extension, waiver, relocation, or termination terms. Do not treat silence as consent without advice.
Related Articles
Primary Authorities Cited
Forgione Deal and Corporate Counsel is a Burlington business law firm acting for owners and buyers in business sales and acquisitions across the GTA, most often valued between $1 million and $15 million. Wes Forgione has closed more than 400 transactions. See: Selling Your Business | Buying a Business.
This article gives general information about Ontario law, current to September 26, 2026. It is not legal advice, and it does not replace advice about your specific lease and transaction. Reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Get advice from a qualified Ontario lawyer and your accountant before signing a purchase agreement or approaching a landlord.
Forgione Deal and Corporate Counsel · Burlington · Mississauga · Oakville · Vaughan · Toronto